Importance of Sources in Writing History

Introduction

History, in its essence, is a meticulous reconstruction of the past. This reconstruction relies heavily on sources, which are the foundational materials necessary for constructing historical narratives. Sources provide the details and context of particular periods, helping us understand the events, cultures, and people of the past. The role of sources in history can be likened to the skeleton of the human body—without them, history would be formless and unsupported. The type and nature of sources utilized shape our perspective of history, underscoring the importance of diverse and reliable sources to create a comprehensive view. This is why there can never be a single, universal history. For all historical facts and events described, there must be definite sources that back up these descriptions. Broadly, sources can be classified into two major groups: literary sources and archaeological sources.

Types of Sources

Literary Sources

Literary sources encompass written records from the past. These sources are further divided into two categories: native literature and foreign literature.

Native Literature

Native literature consists of works produced by individuals within the culture being studied. These sources are invaluable as they provide an insider’s perspective on the historical events, societal norms, and cultural practices of the time. Some notable examples of native literature in the context of Indian history include:

• Vishakadatta’s ‘Mudrarakshasa’: This ancient Indian play provides insights into the political and social life during the time it was written.
• Kalhana’s ‘Rajatarangini’: A historical chronicle of the north-western Indian subcontinent, particularly Kashmir, offering detailed accounts of the region’s history.
• Ashwagosha’s ‘Buddha Charita’: A classical epic poem detailing the life of Buddha, providing valuable information about early Buddhist practices and philosophies.
• Kautilya’s ‘Arthashastra’: An ancient Indian treatise on statecraft, economic policy, and military strategy, which sheds light on governance and administration during its era.
• Buddhist ‘Tripitikas’: A compilation of Buddhist scriptures that offer a wealth of information on the religious, philosophical, and cultural history of Buddhism.
• Srivijaya’s ‘Kavirajamarga’: An early literary work in the Kannada language, providing insights into the language, literature, and culture of its time.

These works are crucial for understanding the internal dynamics, ideologies, and developments within the historical period they cover.

Foreign Literature

Foreign literature includes writings by visitors, explorers, and scholars from outside the culture being studied. These sources provide an external perspective on the society, often highlighting aspects that might be taken for granted or overlooked by native sources. Some significant examples of foreign literary sources relevant to Indian history are:

• Megasthanes’ Indica: An account by the Greek ambassador Megasthenes, who visited the Mauryan Empire. His observations provide a detailed and invaluable account of ancient Indian society, politics, and economy.
• Huien Tsang’s ‘Si-yu-ki’: The travelogues of the Chinese Buddhist monk Huien Tsang, who traveled extensively across India. His works offer a comprehensive view of Indian religious practices, societal structures, and cultural exchanges during his time.
• Fa-hien’s ‘Gho-kho-ki’: Another travelogue by the Chinese monk Fa-hien, documenting his travels in India and providing insights into the Buddhist communities and practices of the era.
• Ceylon’s ‘Deepavamsha’ and ‘Mahavamsha’: Chronicles from Sri Lanka that detail the history of Buddhism and the island’s interactions with the Indian subcontinent.
• Writings of Furneo Nuniz: Accounts by the Portuguese traveler Furneo Nuniz, who visited the Vijayanagar Empire, providing a valuable external perspective on the empire’s grandeur and daily life.
• Accounts of Barbosa and Nicolo Conti: These travelers’ writings offer detailed descriptions of the Vijayanagar Empire’s administration, culture, and economy, adding depth to our understanding of this historical period.

Foreign literary sources are particularly valuable for cross-referencing and validating the information found in native sources, offering a more rounded and objective view of history.

Archaeological Sources

Archaeological sources consist of physical remains from the past, such as inscriptions, coins, monuments, pottery, and other artefacts uncovered during excavations. These sources provide tangible evidence of past civilizations, their lifestyles, and their achievements. Archaeological sources can be classified into several categories:

Inscriptions

Inscriptions are carvings or writings on durable materials like stone, metal, or clay. They often record significant events, decrees, dedications, and other official communications. Inscriptions are vital for understanding the political, social, and economic aspects of past societies. For instance:

• The Edicts of Ashoka: These inscriptions by Emperor Ashoka of the Mauryan dynasty provide insights into his policies, governance, and the spread of Buddhism.
• The Hathigumpha Inscription: An inscription by the Kalinga king Kharavela, detailing his military exploits and contributions to his kingdom.

Coins

Coins are another crucial archaeological source, offering information on the economy, trade, political history, and cultural symbols of the time. They often bear inscriptions and images of rulers, deities, and symbols that help identify historical periods and political entities. For example:

• Gupta Coins: Coins from the Gupta Empire are known for their artistic quality and provide information about the rulers, economy, and cultural practices of the time.
• Roman Coins in India: The presence of Roman coins in India indicates trade relations between the Roman Empire and ancient India.

Monuments

Monuments, such as temples, palaces, and other structures, reflect the architectural styles, religious practices, and societal values of the periods in which they were built. They are key sources for understanding the cultural and technological advancements of past civilizations. Notable examples include:

• The Taj Mahal: An iconic Mughal-era monument that reflects the architectural brilliance and cultural fusion of the period.
• The Ajanta and Ellora Caves: Rock-cut cave monuments that provide insights into the religious and artistic expressions of ancient India.

Pottery and Artefacts

Everyday items, tools, and pottery uncovered during archaeological excavations offer a glimpse into the daily lives and practices of past civilizations. These artefacts help reconstruct the socio-economic conditions, technological advancements, and cultural practices of the time. For instance:

• Harappan Pottery: Pottery from the Indus Valley Civilization provides information about the daily life, trade practices, and artistic achievements of this ancient culture.
• Terracotta Figurines: These figurines, found in various archaeological sites, reflect the artistic expressions and religious beliefs of the people.

Conclusion

Sources are indispensable for the construction of history. They offer detailed insights into past events, shaping our understanding of history. The type of source used determines the perspective of history we gain, emphasizing the need for diverse and reliable sources. Both literary and archaeological sources play crucial roles in piecing together historical narratives, making them the backbone of historical research and study.

In conclusion, the study of history is heavily dependent on the availability and analysis of various sources. Literary sources, both native and foreign, provide written records that offer perspectives from within and outside the culture being studied. Archaeological sources, including inscriptions, coins, monuments, and artefacts, provide physical evidence that complements and corroborates the information found in literary sources. Together, these sources enable historians to construct a detailed and nuanced understanding of past events, cultures, and societies, ensuring that history is not just a collection of stories, but a well-supported narrative based on tangible evidence.

Stay connected with us Install our ClassWork App